Are there any games you'd consider 'perfect'?

[silvertone]

brawl is better than melee

[Hiro]

brawl? wtf shut your whore mouth

What's wrong with Brawl? I don't get why all the Melee fans are so butthurt that it's not the exact same game.

[strongbad]

brawl is better than melee

lol

What's wrong with Brawl? I don't get why all the Melee fans are so butthurt that it's not the exact same game.

Brawl had so many problems. The online play? A joke. The characters are so imbalanced that metaknight is along in the "S" tier and just about every other character is where they are in the tier just to counter metakinght. Also tripping

[Hiro]

lol
Brawl had so many problems. The online play? A joke. The characters are so imbalanced that metaknight is along in the "S" tier and just about every other character is where they are in the tier just to counter metakinght. Also tripping

Online was pretty poor, but the Wii in general is terrible with even handling online. Every Smash Bros game has been imbalanced, and it's supposed to be. None of them are supposed to be solidly balanced technical fighters, they're silly fun games. I have no idea what "S" tier even means.
I've never had a problem with tripping.

Seriously, it's like bashing a mario kart game for not being as realistic as another mario kart.

[Travis]

haha brawl was terrible

[silvertone]

Reasons why Nerds hate Brawl:
1. They Fixed Everything Bad about Melee
2. They Deleted some Shitty Characters
3. They Added the The SmashBall


only 3rd reason is acceptable

[Hiro]

Reasons why Nerds hate Brawl:
1. They Fixed Everything Bad about Melee
2. They Deleted some Shitty Characters
3. They Added the The SmashBall


only 3rd reason is acceptable

You can disable the smash ball though.

[YPrrrr]

Brawl had so many problems. The online play? A joke. The characters are so imbalanced that metaknight is along in the "S" tier and just about every other character is where they are in the tier just to counter metakinght. Also tripping

Melee didn't even have online play. Bad online > no online. Character balancing is almost impossible and if Smashers were organized at all they could just ban Metaknight from tournament play... Maybe they already do?

Tripping is gay, agreed

Reasons why Nerds hate Brawl:
1. They Fixed Everything Bad about Melee
2. They Deleted some Shitty Characters
3. They Added the The SmashBall


only 3rd reason is acceptable

Nerds play without items and all of the deleted characters weren't that competitive anyway

I've never had a problem with tripping.

Then you have not played enough/you play people that suck

[silvertone]

You can disable the smash ball though.

You'd have to be a fool to leave it on.

[Hiro]

Then you have not played enough/you play people that suck

Nope on both counts

[YPrrrr]

Nope on both counts

Yes, if you have not lost a life due to tripping, then you have not played enough or the people you play suck too much to take advantage. There's really no way around it

[Hiro]

Yes, if you have not lost a life due to tripping, then you have not played enough or the people you play suck too much to take advantage. There's really no way around it

I've played the game a shitload, and regularly against a guy who got 2nd place in a college-wide tournament with something like 32 people playing and probably 200 people present

[Kalahari Inkantation]

tripping is the worst decision nintendo's ever made

[spoiler]but overall i'd still say i slightly prefer brawl to melee [/spoiler]

[YPrrrr]

I've played the game a shitload, and regularly against a guy who got 2nd place in a college-wide tournament with something like 32 people playing and probably 200 people present

Ok but seriously, I don't understand how you have never tripped/had it throw off your timing... That just isn't possible.

tripping is the worst decision nintendo's ever made

[spoiler]but overall i'd still say i slightly prefer brawl to melee [/spoiler]

I slightly prefer brawl as well

Probably because of multiple air dodges... I can't go back to just one

[Hiro]

Ok but seriously, I don't understand how you have never tripped/had it throw off your timing... That just isn't possible.

I've tripped, and I'm sure it's thrown off my timing in a few rare instances, but it's still never really been an issue for me.