What are some games that have horrible/mixed reviews that you ended up liking?

[Commander Fuckass]

two of mine are
Silent Hill Homecoming
Silent Hill 4 The Room


those are the ones that I can truly say I actually liked and actually played from beginning to end and actually liked them


It's probably because I love the Silent Hill series but whatevs  

[Kalahari Inkantation]

most of the ace attorney games have mixed reviews for not being video game enough but i love those :'(

[Samus Aran]

Mirror's Edge got a few good reviews here and there, but it mostly got mediocre or even slightly bad reviews...and I fucking love it. It's definitely one of those games that, while it has a really steep learning curve, once you master it, the game becomes infinitely more enjoyable.

It's just the incredibly short length that's holding it back so much.

[Nyerp]

shadow hearts, especially the original one, which got a 5.5 on ign

[Thyme]

Wild Arms 2

[The Hand That Fisted Everyone]

Way of The Samurai series

I spent most of my time with the first one, less time with the second, absolute none with the third

I remember seeing Way of The Samurai get a low score on X-Play and was like what the balls.

[YPrrrr]

I'm having a really hard time thinking of any actually ;

Heretic and Hexen apparently got some mediocre reviews though, and I thought those games were great

[Mando Pandango]

Any of the later Guitar Hero games.

Also Guitar Hero 3 got mostly positive reviews and I consider it an abomination so

[Travis]

Also Guitar Hero 3 got mostly positive reviews and I consider it an abomination so

why that one's the best

[Mando Pandango]

why that one's the best

horrible engine, horrible charting, horrible aesthetics

[Travis]

horrible engine, horrible charting, horrible aesthetics

psyche

[Hiro]

CHIBI ROBO