Rating System

[Wrench]

Nosquid
Squid
Prosquid

[Mando Pandango]

Nosquid
Squid
Prosquid

cheesy as fuck

[Samus Aran]

cheesy as fuck

i have to agree lol

[Wrench]

cheesy as fuck

but you love it

amirite

DAMNIT WHY DO I KEEP FUCKING UP QUOTES

[Thyme]

squidtastic

[wawi]

tentacool
tentacruel

[C.Mongler]

Nosquid
Squid
Prosquid

i love this i'm not gonna lie.

[Samus Aran]

squiddly diddly doo
squiddly diddly poo

[strongbad]

i love this i'm not gonna lie.

Same here.
I think we should actually use it, just because our site won't be featured on Metacritic or anything, so we don't need to worry about a professional scale or anything. I think this is so cheesy that it just might work.

[Nyerp]

there's too much ambiguity in just 3 categories

stick to numbers plz

[C.Mongler]

there's too much ambiguity in just 3 categories

stick to numbers plz

FORCING PEOPLE TO ACTUALLY READ THE REVIEW? FUCK THAT.

3 categories says its good, decent, or bad. Further detail can be explained in the review. The end score is for lazy fucks.

[strongbad]

FORCING PEOPLE TO ACTUALLY READ THE REVIEW? FUCK THAT.

3 categories says its good, decent, or bad. Further detail can be explained in the review. The end score is for lazy fucks.

I agree.

[Samus Aran]

i still say numbers PLUS that extra something

[Thyme]

i still say numbers PLUS that extra something

I still say that as well.

[Thyme]

As a better example, this would kind of be like GiantBomb's reviews with a grade and a drawing of the reviewer doing an expression that echoes the grade.

Like here: http://www.giantbomb.com/tron-evolution/61-29284/reviews/
3 stars and a drawing of the reviewer doing a "so-so" motion with his hand.