November 21, 2024, 02:39:39 PM

1,531,352 Posts in 46,734 Topics by 1,523 Members
› View the most recent posts on the forum.


best led zeppelin album

Started by sans culottes, April 26, 2008, 05:30:13 PM

previous topic - next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

what do you think

Led Zeppelin I
0 (0%)
Led Zeppelin II
0 (0%)
Led Zeppelin III
0 (0%)
Led Zeppelin IV
2 (33.3%)
Houses of the Holy
2 (33.3%)
Physical Grafitti
1 (16.7%)
Presence
0 (0%)
In Through The Out Door
1 (16.7%)

Total Members Voted: 6

Go Down

sans culottes

I pick Houses of the Holy, but I-IV all come close.
I support BUSH

Lovefoxxx


Houdini


Samus Aran

Houses always wins it by just a pinch for me, with PG being second.

Coda is my least favorite.  powerofone;

sans culottes

Even though PG's got brilliant songs, there's some songs that don't appeal to me at all, like Custard Pie or The Rover. Why everyone has it as a runner up, I do not know.
I support BUSH

Samus Aran

Quote from: Co-Z on April 26, 2008, 10:51:38 PM
Even though PG's got brilliant songs, there's some songs that don't appeal to me at all, like Custard Pie or The Rover. Why everyone has it as a runner up, I do not know.


Custard Pie is a bit bland, yes. I do like The Rover, though.

Why wouldn't everyone have it as a runner up? It's clearly better than their last three studio albums. That only leaves their first four to compete with it. It's not hard to see some differing tastes there.

You'd have to be weird to like anything after PG more than PG itself. I can at least say that with confidence.

Houdini

Quote from: Co-Z on April 26, 2008, 10:51:38 PM
Even though PG's got brilliant songs, there's some songs that don't appeal to me at all, like Custard Pie or The Rover. Why everyone has it as a runner up, I do not know.
Weird, Custard Pie is one of my favorites.

sans culottes

Here's my rankings (I look at Coda as more of a compilation of leftovers rather than an album, I tend to seperate it from the eight).

1) Houses of the Holy
2) IV
3) I
4) II
5) III
6) Physical Grafitti
7) In Through The Out Door
8) Presence

(All of I-IV is almost tied for me)

PG is great, but I find their first four albums better than it.
I support BUSH

Andrew1911


Go Up