Stage discussion

[The artist formally known]

Electroplankton stage is awesome, best thing is Pit's forward + B move makes the leaves go crazy

[Geno]

Green Hill Zone. I just love it 

[Daddy]

No Pictochat
No Green Hill Zone
No Yoshi's Island

Final Destination

[greg400]

No Pictochat
No Green Hill Zone
No Yoshi's Island

Final Destination

Nuff said

[Wrench]

I like Pictochat, Castle Siege, Warioware, and Mushroomy Kingdom.

[strongbad]

For fun, Pictochat and the Warioware stages are awesome just for messing around, but for serious battles, final destination will always have my heart.

[Dawei]

I'd say Lylat Cruise, but I always get stuck under the damn edges when I try to recover. ;_;
So I'll just go with Pokemon Stadium 1.

[Squirtlejazz]

Battlefield for serious matches. I like it better than Final D for some reason.
Bridge of Edin is cool.
The new Brinstar is eh.

[Commander Fuckass]

Shadow Moses Island
Castle Siege

[Geno]

Shadow Moses Island

I like it beacause of the walls that surround the stage.

[Feynman]

PIRATE SHIP

[The artist formally known]

Warioware is my favorite really.

[sans culottes]

Corneria is my favorite of all time. Been playing on it a lot since the original Smash (though I'm pretty sure I used to play the DK stage and Saffron City more often back then). During the Melee days, about 3/4 of all Melees I did in multiplayer were on Corneria.

I haven't played enough on the new stages to decide which ones I like best... but most of them have random shit and/or movement going on, lame.

[KonohaShinobi]

No Pictochat
No Green Hill Zone
No Yoshi's Island

Final Destination

This board needs more of this.

[bluaki]

I have complaints about Brawl's stages, I like Melee and 64's stages way better.

Classic style stages suck, touch just one stage hazard to get an instant KO on 75m, Mario Bros , and Flat Zone 2.
Same thing with the spike in Rumble Falls, the bomb in Bridge of Elden, the cars in Mario Circuit and Port Town, and the cannon balls in Pirate Ship.

Items fall off immediately after spawning most of the time in Lylat Cruise, Summit, and Distant Planet

Shadow Moses Island makes any KO other than star KO impossible until the things are broken.

Mushroomy Kingdom 1-1 scrolls too fast and 1-2 blocks almost any star KO for most of the level.

New Pork City and Hyrule Temple are too big and have too many things to bounce off of.

Skyworld's platforms bounce the characters around way too much.

I hate the screen flipping in Spear Pillar.

I hate the reward system in Warioware.

Pokemon Stadium 2's transformations suck compared to the first.

Rainbow Cruise just sucks for many reasons.

Hm... that leaves Battlefield, Final Destination, Delfino Plaza, Luigi's Mansion, Norfair, Frigate Orpheon, Yoshi's Island, Halberd, Castle Siege, Smashville, Pictochat, Hanenbow, and Green Hill Zone of the Brawl stages that I don't dislike.
All the Melee stages, minus Temple and Rainbow Cruise, are pretty good, though I don't particularly like Big Blue or Jungle Japes that much. (leaving Yoshi's Island, Onett, Corneria, Green Greens, Pokemon Stadium, and Brinstar)

I think they should have also kept from Melee: All three N64 stages, Princess Peach's Castle, Dream Fountain, Yoshi's Story, Flat Zone, Mute City, SMB, and SMB2.