Is The Wall the GREATEST ALBUM OF ALL TIME?

[chainsaw unicorn]

There's not a single bad song on the album. Comfortably Numb, Mother, Run Like Hell, and Another Brick in the Wall are some of the greatest songs ever created. Honestly not counting any "Greatest Hits" albums it's probably the best album ever created

[Commander Fuckass]

No

[ncba93ivyase]

[spoiler]atom heart mother is the best pink floyd album[/spoiler]
[spoiler]meddle is also good[/spoiler]



[spoiler]pink floyd isn't very good overall[/spoiler]

[silvertone]

not even best pink floyd album.

[Samus Aran]

are you kidding me the wall has a lot of filler garbage and the whole thing is really shaky conceptually in the first place

"i'm gonna shut myself off from the world completely because of a few barely elucidated fairly slightly traumatic instances of my life"

and waters is at his absolute most ridiculous and whiniest on this album

now Animals, there's a great album

[PLEASEHELP1991]

radiohead is the GREATEST BAND OF ALL TIME

[[hedy]Zidone]

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SBMsulQMqm8[/youtube] hte best songg!!

[Samus Aran]

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SBMsulQMqm8[/youtube] hte best songg!!

for some bizarre reason i own this album on vinyl

then again i own several records that are really bad that i don't own for any particular reason

[[hedy]Zidone]

for some bizarre reason i own this album on vinyl

then again i own several records that are really bad that i don't own for any particular reason

[spoiler]i didn't think it was particularly awful
[glow=black,2,300]at least compared to every other arena rock band[/glow][/spoiler]

[Commander Fuckass]

Linking Park ftw

[Hiro]

for some reason i thought we were talking about dark side of the moon
but yeah the wall's pretty meh
and i'm going to agree with ron and kaz: animals is their best, atom heart mother is 2nd best, but also:

[spoiler]pink floyd isn't very good overall[/spoiler]

[chainsaw unicorn]

[youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SBMsulQMqm8[/youtube] hte best songg!!

What a coincidence, I was listening to Kansas when I saw this post

IMO what makes the wall so great is that it's a very good story of the side effects of having a shitty childhood. It's more psychological than anything

[silvertone]

how the wall proves that sometimes psychological problems happen to people just cos they are a fuckin pussys.

[snoorkel]

"not counting any 'Greatest Hits' albums" ?

[Boogus Epirus Aurelius]

how the wall proves that sometimes psychological problems happen to people just cos they are a fuckin pussys.

Daddy died at war, school is crimpin' my style. Better cut myself off from the whole reality bit.
Maybe that's the point though: flimsy mental stamina.

Everyone knows best Floyd is Wish you Were Here, easy easy.