Boyah Forums

only one option, and no vote changes...so be sure you're voting for what you want to watch.

but what if I want to change my vote to something else when I need to prevent something else from winning?  :(

Quote from: Squid Girl on August 05, 2011, 11:08:58 PM
but what if I want to change my vote to something else when I need to prevent something else from winning?  :(

that underhanded trick is part of the reason we have to do a tiebreaker in the first place

so no echo :|||

Quote from: Suigintou on August 05, 2011, 11:09:42 PM
that underhanded trick is part of the reason we have to do a tiebreaker in the first place

so no echo :|||

It is just politics :|

anime politics

Quote from: Suigintou on August 05, 2011, 11:09:42 PM
that underhanded trick is part of the reason we have to do a tiebreaker in the first place

so no echo :|||

I did it too this time, though it's the first time I have giggle;

Quote from: Suigintou on August 05, 2011, 11:09:42 PM
that underhanded trick is part of the reason we have to do a tiebreaker in the first place

so no echo :|||

I miss those days in the movie threads :(

lol i don't know whether to even count wawi's vote or not

Quote from: bluika on August 05, 2011, 11:17:01 PM
I did it too this time, though it's the first time I have giggle;

I did it for the last two anime polls at least

Quote from: Suigintou on August 05, 2011, 11:21:22 PM
lol i don't know whether to even count wawi's vote or not

lol what did he vote for

EVERY VOTE COUNTS

Quote from: Nyerp on August 05, 2011, 11:31:35 PM
lol what did he vote for

gurren lagann

Quote from: On Stid on August 05, 2011, 11:33:08 PM
EVERY VOTE COUNTS

nnnnn

if i counted his vote and gurren lagann won, and he didn't show up for it, i'd have to ban him or something

i actually wouldn't mind doing that switch-off thing bluaki mentioned for eden and madoka

Quote from: Nyerp on August 06, 2011, 01:39:12 AM
i actually wouldn't mind doing that switch-off thing bluaki mentioned for eden and madoka

nor would i

they're tied anyway

i could see it going like this:

Tuesday:
M â€" 1, 2, 3
E â€" 1
Thursday:
E â€" 2, 3, 4
M â€" 4
Tuesday:
M â€" 5, 6, 7
E â€" 5
Thursday:
E â€" 6, 7, 8
M â€" 8
Tuesday:
M â€" 9, 10, 11
E â€" 9
Thursday:
E â€" 10, 11
M â€" 12

that way they would both end on the same night bassir;

There's still a chance for the poll to change, as three more people voted for the other poll, but I like these results and would prefer for them to stay

Would sub be fine for Eden?

or maybe we should use dub only for the parts that take place in New York and sub for the parts in Japan y/n

Quote from: bluika on August 06, 2011, 01:52:16 AM
There's still a chance for the poll to change, as three more people voted for the other poll, but I like these results and would prefer for them to stay

Would sub be fine for Eden?

or maybe we should use dub only for the parts that take place in New York and sub for the parts in Japan y/n

oh god goonish

that would be silly and probably distracting. sillydood; is the dub any good?

Quote from: Nyerp on August 06, 2011, 01:53:34 AM
oh god goonish

that would be silly and probably distracting. sillydood; is the dub any good?

I didn't try it, so I don't know, but I always prefer sub giggle;
Also I only have the movies as subbed and I think it'd be better to be consistent

Also, the schedule I mentioned earlier would be:
Tuesday: E1, E2, M1, M2
Thursday: E3, E4, M3, M4
Tuesday: E5, E6, M5, M6
Thursday: E7, E8, M7, M8
Tuesday: E9, E10, M9, M10
Thursday: E11, M11, M12, M13

well idk i kind of prefer mine but that's okay too i guess cry;

wait has madoka had a full bd release yet?

Quote from: Nyerp on August 06, 2011, 02:43:58 AM
wait has madoka had a full bd release yet?

It doesn't appear so, but it's not like there's significant changes in the BD, right?

Quote from: bluika on August 06, 2011, 03:23:17 AM
It doesn't appear so, but it's not like there's significant changes in the BD, right?

probably better animation sillydood;

If we watch Eden sub I promise to show up for Madoka every night


plus I can't stand main girls dub voice

you'll promise to show up unless one of your friends happens to want to play a game or something

i've seen ads for the dub of east of eden on a two different dvds i have, and it honestly sounds like just another bland, lifeless funi dub. not one of their better ones.

so i think we should probs go for subs for eden

Quote from: Nyerp on August 06, 2011, 04:16:53 AM
probably better animation sillydood;

I looked at a giant screenshot comparison to learn:
1. The BDs change the fencing on top of the school from regular chain link to some fancy pattern
2. Many minor tweaks to lighting and coloring
3. Mami's house is changed to be decorated like a normal girl's, not as empty and Yuki-like as it was before
4. The same opening is used for all episodes, unlike the TV version where the opening changes occasionally. The BD opening most resembles the one that first appeared in ep6, but with more animation in the transformation scene/part with two madoka hugging each other
5. Some other minor tweaks in the background

Though all these minor tweaks are improvements, they're hardly noticeable and don't significantly affect the quality.

Also, after these three weeks of Madoka/Eden, will we watch the two Eden movies on Tuesday and Thursday of the fourth week?

madoka is apparently in the lead now, if that matters

Quote from: bluika on August 06, 2011, 02:12:42 PM
Also, after these three weeks of Madoka/Eden, will we watch the two Eden movies on Tuesday and Thursday of the fourth week?

i guess?????

anyway i guess this is basically official now so i changed the thread title to reflect it

and i assume we're going with blu's schedule idea

but seeing the first 3 episodes of madoka at once is a better hook :'(

Quote from: Nyerp on August 07, 2011, 06:48:07 PM
but seeing the first 3 episodes of madoka at once is a better hook :'(

yeahh...that's true, it is :'(