A comprehensive list of things that Breath of the Wild does well:

[Samus Aran]

it's not my least favorite Zelda game ever, but TP is at least my least favorite 3D Zelda

[Thyme]

it's not my least favorite Zelda game ever, but TP is at least my least favorite 3D Zelda

of the ones i played, same
i haven't played SS

[Samus Aran]

Skyward Sword, as incredibly flawed as it may be, still ended up being better written than TP and is a very aesthetically pleasing game if nothing else, whereas TP is butt uggo

[Kalahari Inkantation]

i haven't played SS

let's keep it that way

[Samus Aran]

but it has bomb bowling!!!

it's funny because despite that feature, there's no bomb bowling minigame and there actually was an effective bomb bowling minigame in Ocarina of Time

[Hiro]

it's not my least favorite Zelda game ever, but TP is at least my least favorite 3D Zelda

yeah same

Skyward Sword, as incredibly flawed as it may be, still ended up being better written than TP and is a very aesthetically pleasing game if nothing else, whereas TP is butt uggo

SS is somewhere in the middle of my Zelda rankings, definitely far from great but I had fun with it and there's some good things to be said about it
Really if any Zelda games have ever needed remakes, I would say Majora's Mask, Skyward Sword, and Zelda II are the prime candidates.

but it has bomb bowling!!!

it's funny because despite that feature, there's no bomb bowling minigame and there actually was an effective bomb bowling minigame in Ocarina of Time

also running up large enemies' shields to get behind them was sweet

[TooB]

I can't agree with SS being better than TP at all.

[Samus Aran]

A comprehensive list of things that Twilight Princess does well:

-amazing Hyrule field theme, some of the other music is quite good too
-good Ganondorf swordfight (almost makes up for the terrible beast Ganon fight)
-Midna is an enjoyable character imo
-enhanced Wind Waker's combat system. some of the new moves are kinda awkward but it's overall an improvement
-Wolf Link is fun to play as (but unfortunately most of the time being in the Twilight world is NOT fun)

i think this is a good list. there are about four times as many things i could put in a list of problems with the game

[TooB]

That's more done well than SS

[Kalahari Inkantation]

hot take: most tp fans really just like midna's arse

[silvertone]

i like the yeti level a lot. being a wolf in the mountain is so cool

[TooB]

hot take: most tp fans really just like midna's arse

not "just" to be fair lol

[Hiro]

I think the production value is solid, music is good, and for its time the map was a big improvement for the series
there's some fun dungeons too I suppose, and Midna is an alright character
but yeah if we're going to critique TP that should probably be a different thread

hot take: most tp fans really just like midna's arse

her design is oddly sexual imo

That's more done well than SS

i like the yeti level a lot. being a wolf in the mountain is so cool

honestly that level is one of my least favorite dungeons in any Zelda

[TooB]

Dancing baby, eh?

[The Hand That Fisted Everyone]

i beat twilight princess and can't tell you anything ab out it except for wolf link, shadow with the orange hand, and the Malo Mart theme